Skip to main content
ponderloop

Rent vs Buy Calculator

For a $400,000 home with 20% down, a 6.5% 30-year mortgage and $2,200 a month in rent, buying breaks even in year 9: after 10 years buying leaves $234,029.33 of net worth against $225,253.71 for renting, so buying is ahead by $8,775.62. Net worth if buying is the home’s value minus the loan balance and selling costs, plus any savings invested; net worth if renting is the down payment and every monthly saving, invested at 5% a year while the home grows 3% a year. Change any input, including the years to compare, to see your own break-even year, total cash paid and a year-by-year table. This is an estimate, not financial advice.

Updated Runs in your browser: nothing you enter is uploadedHow this tool works

Buying
Renting
Comparison

Buying breaks even in year 9

After 10 years: buying leaves $234,029.33, renting leaves $225,253.71; buying is ahead by $8,775.62.

Net worth if buying
$234,029.33
Net worth if renting
$225,253.71
Buying minus renting
$8,775.62
Break-even year
Year 9
Total cash paid, buying
$451,646.36
Total cash paid, renting
$304,939.08
Home value at the end
$537,566.56
Loan balance at the end
$271,283.24
Selling costs at the end
$32,253.99
Mortgage payment (principal and interest)
$2,022.62
Monthly cost in year 1, buying
$2,872.62
Monthly cost in year 1, renting
$2,216.67

An estimate, not advice: it uses constant rates, no taxes or tax deductions, and leaves out the costs and risks listed under “What the model leaves out”.

Year by year

Net worth if buying and if renting at the end of each of the 10 years, and which is ahead.
YearHome valueLoan balanceNet worth if buyingNet worth if rentingBuying minus rentingAhead
1$412,000.00$316,423.24$70,856.76$104,761.21−$33,904.45Renting
2$424,360.00$312,606.96$86,291.44$117,671.89−$31,380.45Renting
3$437,090.80$308,535.08$102,330.27$130,724.66−$28,394.39Renting
4$450,203.52$304,190.51$119,000.80$143,911.14−$24,910.34Renting
5$463,709.63$299,554.97$136,332.08$157,222.17−$20,890.09Renting
6$477,620.92$294,608.97$154,354.69$170,647.63−$16,292.94Renting
7$491,949.55$289,331.75$173,100.83$184,176.37−$11,075.54Renting
8$506,708.04$283,701.10$192,604.46$197,795.95−$5,191.49Renting
9$521,909.28$277,693.35$212,901.37$211,493.39$1,407.98Buying
10$537,566.56$271,283.24$234,029.33$225,253.71$8,775.62Buying

The working

  1. Purchase: down payment 20% × $400,000.00 = $80,000.00; closing costs 3% × $400,000.00 = $12,000.00; loan = $320,000.00.
  2. Mortgage: 6.5% a year ÷ 12 ≈ 0.5417% a month over 360 months gives a payment of $2,022.62 (principal and interest).
  3. Year 1 owning, per month: mortgage $2,022.62 + property tax $366.67 + insurance $150.00 + maintenance $333.33 = $2,872.62.
  4. Year 1 renting, per month: rent $2,200.00 + renter’s insurance $16.67 = $2,216.67.
  5. Savings: the renter invests $92,000.00 (down payment + closing costs) on day one. Every month the side that spends less invests the difference. Both earn 5% a year, ≈ 0.4167% a month, compounded monthly.
  6. After 10 years the home is worth $537,566.56 (3% a year, one step each year). Selling costs 6% = $32,253.99; loan balance $271,283.24.
  7. Buying: $537,566.56 − $271,283.24 − $32,253.99 + $0.00 invested savings = $234,029.33.
  8. Renting: $225,253.71 invested (down payment, closing costs and monthly differences) = $225,253.71.
  9. Break-even: year 9 is the first year-end where buying’s net worth is higher than renting’s.

Break-even year by rent-to-price ratio and home price growth

Break-even year for a $400,000 home as the monthly rent changes (rent ÷ price) and the home price grows 0% to 5% a year; everything else as in the example (20% down, 6.5% mortgage, 3% rent growth, 5% return on savings). The price-to-rent ratio is the price divided by 12 months of rent. Searched up to 30 years.
Monthly rentRent ÷ pricePrice-to-rent ratioHome price growth 0%Home price growth 2%Home price growth 3%Home price growth 4%Home price growth 5%
$1,6000.4%20.8Not in 30 yearsNot in 30 yearsNot in 30 yearsNot in 30 yearsYear 11
$2,0000.5%16.7Not in 30 yearsYear 26Year 16Year 8Year 5
$2,2000.55%15.2Year 24Year 16Year 9Year 6Year 4
$2,4000.6%13.9Year 18Year 10Year 6Year 4Year 3
$2,8000.7%11.9Year 10Year 5Year 4Year 3Year 3
$3,2000.8%10.4Year 6Year 4Year 3Year 2Year 2
$3,6000.9%9.3Year 4Year 3Year 2Year 2Year 2
$4,0001%8.3Year 3Year 2Year 2Year 2Year 2

Break-even year by mortgage rate and return on savings

Break-even year for the example ($400,000, 20% down, $2,200 rent, 3% home price growth) as the mortgage rate and the return on invested savings change. Searched up to 30 years.
Mortgage rateReturn on savings 0%Return on savings 3%Return on savings 5%Return on savings 7%Return on savings 9%
4%Year 3Year 3Year 4Year 5Year 6
5%Year 3Year 4Year 5Year 7Not in 30 years
6%Year 4Year 5Year 7Year 14Not in 30 years
6.5%Year 5Year 6Year 9Not in 30 yearsNot in 30 years
7%Year 5Year 8Year 12Not in 30 yearsNot in 30 years
8%Year 7Year 12Year 22Not in 30 yearsNot in 30 years

What a 5, 10 or 20-year horizon changes

The example ($400,000 home, $2,200 rent) at the end of 5, 10 and 20 years. Selling costs of 6% are taken off the home value in the buyer’s net worth.
YearsHome valueLoan balanceSelling costsNet worth if buyingNet worth if rentingBuying minus rentingAhead
5 years$463,709.63$299,554.97$27,822.58$136,332.08$157,222.17−$20,890.09Renting
10 years$537,566.56$271,283.24$32,253.99$234,029.33$225,253.71$8,775.62Buying
20 years$722,444.52$178,127.79$43,346.67$517,422.49$378,515.13$138,907.36Buying

Cost components of owning: the example in year 1 and over 10 years

What owning the $400,000 example costs, split into parts. “Return given up” is what the down payment and closing costs would have earned at 5% if invested instead. Mortgage principal is not a cost: it becomes equity.
ComponentYear 1Over 10 years
Mortgage interest$20,694.68$193,997.64
Property tax$4,400.04$50,441.28
Home insurance$1,800.00$20,635.20
Maintenance$3,999.96$45,855.48
Closing costs (paid once, at the start)$12,000.00$12,000.00
Selling costs (paid once, at the end)—$32,253.99
Return given up on the down payment and closing costs$4,706.88$59,524.79
Total cost of owning that builds no equity$47,601.56$414,708.38
Home value gain (reduces the cost)$12,000.00$137,566.56
Net cost of owning (total cost minus home value gain)$35,601.56$277,141.82
Mortgage principal repaid (builds equity, not a cost)$3,576.76$48,716.76
For comparison: rent and renter’s insurance paid$26,600.04$304,939.08

How to compare renting with buying a home

  1. Enter the home price, down payment and mortgage. Type the price, the down payment as a percentage, the mortgage rate and the term in years. Add the closing costs as a percentage of the price.
  2. Add the yearly costs of owning. Enter property tax and maintenance as a percentage of the home’s value each year, and home insurance in dollars per year. Leave a box empty to count it as zero.
  3. Set home price growth and selling costs. Enter how fast you assume the home’s price grows each year (it can be negative) and the percentage you would pay to sell.
  4. Enter the rent. Type the monthly rent for a comparable place, how fast it rises each year and the yearly cost of renter’s insurance.
  5. Choose the years and the return on savings. Pick how many years you expect to stay (1 to 40) and the yearly return you assume on money not spent on the house. Read the break-even year, the two net worths and the year-by-year table.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to rent or buy a home?
It depends on the numbers and on how long you stay, and no calculator can say for you. In the example, buying costs $2,872.62 a month in year 1 against $2,216.67 for renting, yet buying is ahead after 10 years by $8,775.62 because the loan is paid down and the home gains value. Change the rent, the price growth or the return on savings and the answer can flip: with the home price flat (0% growth) the example’s break-even is year 24, and at 5% growth it is year 4. This is an estimate for comparing, not financial advice.
How does the calculator find the break-even year?
At the end of every year it works out two net worths. Buying: home value − loan balance − selling costs + any savings invested. Renting: the down payment and closing costs invested on day one, plus every month the renter spends less than the owner. The break-even year is the first year in which buying’s net worth is higher. For the example that is year 9: $1,407.98 ahead at the end of that year, against −$5,191.49 a year earlier. If buying never gets ahead within the years you chose, the result says so instead of giving a year, and if buying leads for a while and then falls behind again, a note says so.
How long do I need to stay in a home for buying to pay off?
In the example it takes until year 9. Selling costs and closing costs are paid once whatever the length of stay, so a short stay spreads them over few years. Buying minus renting in net worth is −$20,890.09 at 5 years, $8,775.62 at 10 years and $138,907.36 at 20 years (a negative number means renting is ahead). At the end of year 10 the selling costs alone are $32,253.99. Your break-even year will differ; the first table above shows how the rent-to-price ratio and price growth move it.
Why can renting win when rent is “money thrown away”?
Part of owning is also money that does not come back: in the example’s first year, mortgage interest is $20,694.68, property tax $4,400.04 and maintenance $3,999.96, plus insurance and the return the down payment could have earned. Rent buys a place to live; the renter who spends less each month and invests the $92,000.00 that the buyer puts into the house ends the example’s 10 years with $225,253.71. The $92,000.00 alone would grow to $151,524.79 at 5% a year. Renting tends to win when rents are low compared with prices, when the home’s price grows slowly, when the return on investments is high, when mortgage rates are high, or when you move soon.
What is the 5% rule, and does it match this calculator?
The 5% rule is a rule of thumb, not a result of this model. It says the yearly costs of owning that you never get back (property tax, maintenance and the cost of the money tied up in the house) add up to roughly 5% of the home’s value, so renting is cheaper if a year of rent is below 5% of the value, that is, if monthly rent is below value × 5% ÷ 12. For the $400,000 example that threshold is $1,666.67 a month; the example rent of $2,200 is above it, so the rule of thumb leans to buying, while this calculator finds buying ahead after 10 years. The 5% itself is a convention that depends on interest rates, tax and growth, so use it for a first look only. For comparison, the calculator’s own count for the example’s first year (mortgage interest, property tax, insurance and maintenance) is 7.72% of the price before any price growth and 4.72% after the example’s 3% a year of price growth, and neither counts the return the down payment could earn. The rule of thumb and this model count different things, so they need not agree.
What costs of owning do people forget?
Closing costs ($12,000.00 in the example), property tax, home insurance and maintenance, and the cost of selling. Over 10 years the example pays $50,441.28 in property tax, $20,635.20 in insurance and $45,855.48 in maintenance on top of $193,997.64 in mortgage interest, and $32,253.99 to sell. All told the buyer pays $451,646.36 in cash over those years (down payment, closing costs and every monthly cost), the renter $304,939.08. The cost-components table lists each part for year 1 and for the whole period. Costs the model does not count are listed below.
How much does the return on savings matter?
A lot, because the renter invests the down payment and closing costs. In the example the break-even is year 6 with a 3% return, year 9 at 5%, no break-even within 30 years at 7% and no break-even within 30 years at 9%. A higher return favors renting, a lower one favors buying. Returns are not guaranteed and a real portfolio moves up and down, while the calculator uses one steady rate; treat the return as an assumption to test, not a forecast.
How much does home price growth matter?
It moves the result a lot, because growth applies to the whole home, not just your down payment. With the example’s other numbers, break-even is year 24 at 0% growth, year 16 at 2%, year 9 at 3% and year 4 at 5%. The model uses the same growth every year; real prices rise and fall, and a home bought at a peak can lose value. Try a negative number to see a falling market.
Does a bigger down payment change the answer?
A larger down payment means a smaller loan and less interest, but it is also more cash the renter could have invested. With a 6.5% mortgage and a 5% return on savings, cash put into the house avoids interest at a higher rate than it would earn invested, which helps buying here. In the example, break-even is year 10 with 10% down, year 9 with 20% and year 8 with 40%. The calculator does not add mortgage insurance for small down payments, which some lenders require, so a low down payment can look better here than it is.
What is the price-to-rent ratio?
It is the home price divided by a year of rent for a similar home. The example is $400,000 ÷ (12 × $2,200) = 15.2. A higher ratio means homes are expensive compared with renting, which tends to favor renting; a lower ratio favors buying. The first table shows the ratio next to each rent level and the break-even year at different home price growth rates.
How are the savings invested, and what return is used?
The renter invests $92,000.00 on day one, and each month whoever spends less on housing invests the difference. The yearly return you enter is applied as a nominal rate divided by 12 every month, so 5% a year grows money by 5.12% over a full year when compounded. Deposits go in at the end of each month. There is no tax on the investment return and no fees, and the same return applies to both sides.
Does the calculator include tax deductions or capital gains tax?
No. Tax rules differ by country and change over time. In some places mortgage interest or property tax can lower an income tax bill, and part of the profit on selling a main home can be excluded from tax; investment returns can be taxed too. The model includes none of this, in either direction, so it will not match a tax-adjusted comparison. Ask a tax professional about your own situation.
What does the model leave out?
Income and capital gains taxes and deductions, mortgage insurance, homeowners’ association fees, utilities and other costs that differ between owning and renting, the cost of moving, refinancing and changing interest rates, renovations, a loan with a variable rate, rent control or large rent jumps, and the risk that prices or investments fall. It also leaves out what is not money: stability, space to change the home, and the freedom to move. Insurance and rent grow with the rates you enter, property tax is a flat share of the home’s value, and the home and the portfolio each earn one steady rate. That makes the result an estimate to compare scenarios, not a forecast or advice.
What happens after the mortgage is paid off?
The payment stops, and owning then costs only property tax, insurance and maintenance, so the owner’s monthly outlay falls and the owner starts investing the difference. If you compare more years than the mortgage term, the page says so. In the example the 30-year loan is still $271,283.24 of the original $320,000.00 at the end of year 10.
Why is my result different from another rent vs buy calculator?
Calculators differ in what they include: tax deductions, mortgage insurance, how rent and costs are inflated, when the renter starts to invest, and how often interest compounds. This one counts property tax and maintenance as a share of the home’s value at the start of each year, grows home insurance with the home price and renter’s insurance with the rent, and lets the side that spends less invest the difference every month. Compare the assumptions, not just the answers.

How it works

Buying: the down payment is the price × the down payment %, and the loan is the rest. Closing costs (price × closing %) are paid in cash at the start. The monthly payment is M = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n) with r = mortgage rate ÷ 12 and n months, computed exactly in whole cents and rounded half up once; each month’s interest is the balance × r, rounded half up. After the term the loan is gone and the payment is zero. Once a year, at the end of the year, the home value, home insurance, rent and renter’s insurance are each multiplied by (1 + their growth rate) and rounded half up to the cent; home insurance follows the home price growth and renter’s insurance follows the rent growth. Property tax and maintenance for a year are a percentage of the home’s value at the start of that year. Each yearly cost is paid as 12 equal monthly amounts, rounded half up to the cent. Savings: the renter invests the down payment and closing costs on day one. Each month, the side whose housing outlay (mortgage payment, tax, insurance and maintenance for the owner; rent and renter’s insurance for the renter) is lower invests the difference at the end of the month. Both portfolios grow by the yearly return ÷ 12 each month, rounded half up to the cent, and no tax or fee is taken. Net worth at the end of each year: buying = home value − loan balance − selling costs (the selling % × the home value) + the buyer’s invested savings; renting = the renter’s invested savings. The break-even year is the first year in which buying’s net worth is higher. Total cash paid counts the down payment, closing costs, mortgage payments, tax, insurance and maintenance for buying, and rent and renter’s insurance for renting; selling costs are shown separately. Nothing is deducted from tax, rates are constant, and the figures are an estimate for comparing scenarios, not financial advice.

Sources

More: Loans and mortgagesAll money & costsAll toolsHome & DIY calculators