Student Loan Payoff Strategies Compared, With Numbers
On a $30,000 loan at 6%, $100 extra a month saves $3,046.34 and finishes 34 months early. How extra payments, refinancing and accrued interest compare.
On a $30,000 loan at 6% with a standard 10-year term, the payment is $333.06 a month and the interest over the life of the loan is $9,967.43. Adding $100 a month finishes 34 months sooner and saves $3,046.34. Stretching the term to 20 years drops the payment to $214.93 but raises the interest to $21,582.74. The rate is illustrative, not a quote, and this is general information, not financial advice.
How interest accrues
One common way to charge interest is simple daily interest: each day adds balance × annual rate ÷ 365 to what you owe, and your loan terms say whether yours works this way. That interest builds on the principal, and it only earns more interest itself once it is added to the balance (see capitalization below). The tools linked here approximate repayment with a monthly rate of the annual rate ÷ 12, which gives nearly the same answer over a year.
For the $30,000 loan at 6%:
| Period | Interest |
|---|---|
| 1 day (6% ÷ 365) | $4.93 |
| 30 days | $147.95 |
| 31 days | $152.88 |
| One month at the annual rate ÷ 12 | $150.00 |
| 365 days | $1,800.00 |
Because a payment first covers the interest that has built up and only then reduces principal, a payment smaller than the interest does not shrink the loan. A $120 monthly payment on this loan leaves $30,030.00 owed after month 1 and $30,370.06 after month 12, because the first month’s interest of $150.00 is larger than the payment. Any strategy has to start by paying more than the interest.
The strategies, side by side
Four common approaches, applied to the same $30,000 at 6% (the refinance rate of 4.5% is a hypothetical offer):
| Strategy | Monthly payment | Months to pay off | Total interest |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard, 10 years | $333.06 | 120 | $9,967.43 |
| Standard plus $100 extra | $433.06 | 86 | $6,921.09 |
| Extended, 20 years | $214.93 | 240 | $21,582.74 |
| Refinanced to 4.5%, 10 years | $310.92 | 120 | $7,309.65 |
| Refinanced to 4.5%, plus $100 extra | $410.92 | 86 | $5,119.71 |
A lower payment means a longer loan and more interest. A lower rate and extra payments both cut interest, and they stack.
Standard repayment
A standard plan uses a level payment that clears the loan over a fixed term: payment = P × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n), with r the monthly rate and n the number of months. Early payments are mostly interest; later ones are mostly principal.
Extra payments
Extra money goes to principal once the month’s interest is covered, so the next month’s interest is charged on a smaller balance. With several loans, putting the extra on the highest rate saves the most, the same avalanche logic described for debts in general. Check that your servicer applies extra money to principal.
Refinancing
Refinancing replaces your loan with a new one, ideally at a lower rate. Above, dropping from 6% to 4.5% cuts the payment by $22.14 a month and the total interest by $2,657.78 on the same 10-year term. Before refinancing, find out which protections or repayment options attached to the old loan would not carry over. Details differ between lenders and loan types.
Income-driven plans
Some repayment plans set your payment from your income and household size rather than from your balance and a fixed term. That can lower the payment a lot, but the same trade-off applies: a smaller payment spreads the debt over more time, and if it is below the monthly interest the balance can grow. Eligibility, formulas, plan length and the treatment of any remaining balance are set by the program and change over time, so this guide does not state them. For current federal terms, use studentaid.gov.
Capitalization: when interest becomes principal
Capitalization means unpaid interest is added to the loan balance, so from then on it earns interest too. It often matters most when a loan sits unpaid for a while, for example during school and a grace period.
Take the same $30,000 at 6%, with 48 months in school and a 6-month grace period before repayment. That is 54 months, or 1,643 days by the 365-day-year convention used here, and simple interest over that time comes to $8,102.47.
| What happens to that interest | Owed at start | Monthly payment | Months | Total interest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nothing built up (paid as it came) | $30,000.00 | $333.06 | 120 | $9,967.43 |
| Added to the balance (capitalized) | $38,102.47 | $423.02 | 120 | $20,761.70 |
| Kept apart, earning nothing | $38,102.47 | $423.02 | 118 | $19,692.50 |
The last column includes the $8,102.47 for the two accrued rows. Capitalizing costs $1,069.20 more than keeping the accrued interest as a separate pile that earns nothing, and raises the payment by $89.96 compared with a loan that had no build-up. Whether and when interest capitalizes depends on your loan terms, so read your loan documents. Paying the accruing interest while still in school keeps the loan at its original size.
Choosing a strategy
- Pay more than the interest first. Everything else depends on that.
- Extra payments are flexible: you can stop when cash is tight, and the standard payment stays as the floor.
- A longer term or income-based payment eases the monthly strain at the price of more interest, and can be right when the alternative is missed payments.
- Refinancing helps only if the new rate is lower after fees and what you give up.
- Several loans: keep the total monthly amount constant as loans close and direct extra money to the highest rate. The debt payoff calculator compares that with smallest-balance-first.
Try it
Enter your loans, school and grace months, term and extra payment in the student loan calculator to see the accrued interest, the payment, the payoff month for each loan and the full schedule. The model is a simplification (simple daily interest before repayment, annual rate ÷ 12 after), and real servicers apply their own rules, so treat results as estimates. Every figure here was computed with exact decimal arithmetic.
Updated 2026-11-04