ponderloop.com

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Buying
Renting
Comparison

Buying breaks even in year 9

After 10 years: buying leaves $234,029.33, renting leaves $225,253.71; buying is ahead by $8,775.62.

Net worth if buying
$234,029.33
Net worth if renting
$225,253.71
Buying minus renting
$8,775.62
Break-even year
Year 9
Total cash paid, buying
$451,646.36
Total cash paid, renting
$304,939.08
Home value at the end
$537,566.56
Loan balance at the end
$271,283.24
Selling costs at the end
$32,253.99
Mortgage payment (principal and interest)
$2,022.62
Monthly cost in year 1, buying
$2,872.62
Monthly cost in year 1, renting
$2,216.67

An estimate, not advice: it uses constant rates, no taxes or tax deductions, and leaves out the costs and risks listed under “What the model leaves out”.

Year by year

Net worth if buying and if renting at the end of each of the 10 years, and which is ahead.
YearHome valueLoan balanceNet worth if buyingNet worth if rentingBuying minus rentingAhead
1$412,000.00$316,423.24$70,856.76$104,761.21−$33,904.45Renting
2$424,360.00$312,606.96$86,291.44$117,671.89−$31,380.45Renting
3$437,090.80$308,535.08$102,330.27$130,724.66−$28,394.39Renting
4$450,203.52$304,190.51$119,000.80$143,911.14−$24,910.34Renting
5$463,709.63$299,554.97$136,332.08$157,222.17−$20,890.09Renting
6$477,620.92$294,608.97$154,354.69$170,647.63−$16,292.94Renting
7$491,949.55$289,331.75$173,100.83$184,176.37−$11,075.54Renting
8$506,708.04$283,701.10$192,604.46$197,795.95−$5,191.49Renting
9$521,909.28$277,693.35$212,901.37$211,493.39$1,407.98Buying
10$537,566.56$271,283.24$234,029.33$225,253.71$8,775.62Buying

The working

  1. Purchase: down payment 20% × $400,000.00 = $80,000.00; closing costs 3% × $400,000.00 = $12,000.00; loan = $320,000.00.
  2. Mortgage: 6.5% a year ÷ 12 ≈ 0.5417% a month over 360 months gives a payment of $2,022.62 (principal and interest).
  3. Year 1 owning, per month: mortgage $2,022.62 + property tax $366.67 + insurance $150.00 + maintenance $333.33 = $2,872.62.
  4. Year 1 renting, per month: rent $2,200.00 + renter’s insurance $16.67 = $2,216.67.
  5. Savings: the renter invests $92,000.00 (down payment + closing costs) on day one. Every month the side that spends less invests the difference. Both earn 5% a year, ≈ 0.4167% a month, compounded monthly.
  6. After 10 years the home is worth $537,566.56 (3% a year, one step each year). Selling costs 6% = $32,253.99; loan balance $271,283.24.
  7. Buying: $537,566.56 − $271,283.24 − $32,253.99 + $0.00 invested savings = $234,029.33.
  8. Renting: $225,253.71 invested (down payment, closing costs and monthly differences) = $225,253.71.
  9. Break-even: year 9 is the first year-end where buying’s net worth is higher than renting’s.