Rent vs Buy Calculator
Buying breaks even in year 9
After 10 years: buying leaves $234,029.33, renting leaves $225,253.71; buying is ahead by $8,775.62.
- Net worth if buying
- $234,029.33
- Net worth if renting
- $225,253.71
- Buying minus renting
- $8,775.62
- Break-even year
- Year 9
- Total cash paid, buying
- $451,646.36
- Total cash paid, renting
- $304,939.08
- Home value at the end
- $537,566.56
- Loan balance at the end
- $271,283.24
- Selling costs at the end
- $32,253.99
- Mortgage payment (principal and interest)
- $2,022.62
- Monthly cost in year 1, buying
- $2,872.62
- Monthly cost in year 1, renting
- $2,216.67
An estimate, not advice: it uses constant rates, no taxes or tax deductions, and leaves out the costs and risks listed under “What the model leaves out”.
Year by year
| Year | Home value | Loan balance | Net worth if buying | Net worth if renting | Buying minus renting | Ahead |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $412,000.00 | $316,423.24 | $70,856.76 | $104,761.21 | −$33,904.45 | Renting |
| 2 | $424,360.00 | $312,606.96 | $86,291.44 | $117,671.89 | −$31,380.45 | Renting |
| 3 | $437,090.80 | $308,535.08 | $102,330.27 | $130,724.66 | −$28,394.39 | Renting |
| 4 | $450,203.52 | $304,190.51 | $119,000.80 | $143,911.14 | −$24,910.34 | Renting |
| 5 | $463,709.63 | $299,554.97 | $136,332.08 | $157,222.17 | −$20,890.09 | Renting |
| 6 | $477,620.92 | $294,608.97 | $154,354.69 | $170,647.63 | −$16,292.94 | Renting |
| 7 | $491,949.55 | $289,331.75 | $173,100.83 | $184,176.37 | −$11,075.54 | Renting |
| 8 | $506,708.04 | $283,701.10 | $192,604.46 | $197,795.95 | −$5,191.49 | Renting |
| 9 | $521,909.28 | $277,693.35 | $212,901.37 | $211,493.39 | $1,407.98 | Buying |
| 10 | $537,566.56 | $271,283.24 | $234,029.33 | $225,253.71 | $8,775.62 | Buying |
The working
- Purchase: down payment 20% × $400,000.00 = $80,000.00; closing costs 3% × $400,000.00 = $12,000.00; loan = $320,000.00.
- Mortgage: 6.5% a year ÷ 12 ≈ 0.5417% a month over 360 months gives a payment of $2,022.62 (principal and interest).
- Year 1 owning, per month: mortgage $2,022.62 + property tax $366.67 + insurance $150.00 + maintenance $333.33 = $2,872.62.
- Year 1 renting, per month: rent $2,200.00 + renter’s insurance $16.67 = $2,216.67.
- Savings: the renter invests $92,000.00 (down payment + closing costs) on day one. Every month the side that spends less invests the difference. Both earn 5% a year, ≈ 0.4167% a month, compounded monthly.
- After 10 years the home is worth $537,566.56 (3% a year, one step each year). Selling costs 6% = $32,253.99; loan balance $271,283.24.
- Buying: $537,566.56 − $271,283.24 − $32,253.99 + $0.00 invested savings = $234,029.33.
- Renting: $225,253.71 invested (down payment, closing costs and monthly differences) = $225,253.71.
- Break-even: year 9 is the first year-end where buying’s net worth is higher than renting’s.